top of page

Enhancing Organizational Security: Tailoring NIST 800-53

Updated: Feb 28

NIST 800-53 refers to the publication titled "Security and Privacy Controls for Information Systems and Organizations" by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in the United States. It provides a comprehensive set of security and privacy controls that organizations can use to protect their information systems and data.

NIST 800-53 is part of the Special Publication 800-series, which offers guidance on various aspects of information security and privacy. It is widely recognized and adopted by government agencies, contractors, and other organizations to establish and maintain effective security programs.

The publication outlines a catalog of security controls, organized into 18 families, that address different aspects of information security. These families cover areas such as access control, incident response, system and information integrity, risk assessment, and security awareness training. Each control is accompanied by guidance on implementation, assessment, and monitoring.

The controls provided in NIST 800-53 are risk-based, meaning they are designed to address specific security risks faced by an organization. The document emphasizes the importance of tailoring the controls to meet the unique needs of an organization and its specific information systems.

NIST 800-53 is regularly updated to keep pace with evolving threats, technologies, and best practices.

Overall, NIST 800-53 serves as a valuable resource for organizations seeking to establish a robust security and privacy framework for their information systems, and it provides a foundation for compliance with various security and privacy regulations and standards.

The Flaws & Limitations of NIST 800-53

While NIST 800-53 is widely regarded as a comprehensive and authoritative framework for information security controls, it is not without its potential flaws or limitations. Here are a few aspects that some critics and practitioners have pointed out:

  1. Complexity: NIST 800-53 is a highly detailed and extensive document, which can make it challenging to navigate and implement effectively. Some organizations may find it overwhelming, especially if they lack the necessary expertise or resources to interpret and apply the controls appropriately.

  2. Lack of Flexibility: The controls provided in NIST 800-53 are designed to be tailored to the specific needs of an organization. However, some critics argue that the framework still leans towards a one-size-fits-all approach and may not adequately accommodate the diverse requirements of different industries, sectors, or organizational sizes.

  3. Lag in Addressing Emerging Technologies: Due to the lengthy development and update cycles, NIST 800-53 may not always keep pace with rapidly evolving technology landscapes. This lag can result in controls that are not specifically designed to address emerging technologies or new security threats adequately.

  4. Limited Coverage of Certain Areas: While NIST 800-53 covers a wide range of security controls, some argue that certain areas, such as emerging fields like cloud computing, mobile security, or Internet of Things (IoT), may not be adequately addressed or may require additional guidance beyond what the framework offers.

  5. Potential for Compliance-Driven Approaches: Some organizations may fall into the trap of adopting a checkbox approach to compliance, focusing solely on meeting the prescribed controls without fully understanding their specific risks or tailoring the controls to their unique environment. This can lead to a false sense of security and may not necessarily result in effective protection against advanced threats.

It's important to note that NIST is aware of these concerns and continuously strives to improve the framework. They actively seek feedback from practitioners, conduct workshops, and collaborate with industry experts to enhance the controls and address emerging challenges. Organizations are encouraged to review and interpret the controls in the context of their specific needs, risk profiles, and industry best practices, and to supplement the framework with additional guidance and frameworks as necessary.

Tailoring NIST 800-53 for Your Organization

NIST 800-53 controls are risk-based and NIST 800-53 emphasizes the importance of tailoring the controls to meet the unique needs of an organization and its specific information systems.

This can be accomplished by using X-Analytics (or other cyber risk decision platform). The selection and prioritization of NIST 800-53 controls is based on the organizations:

  • Exposure Profile: An organization's exposure profile is the unique combination of industry vertical, annual revenue, types of volume of data records, value of intellectual property, number of employees, and many other profile elements. These elements inform the types of associated cyber loss categories and the potential severity of such categories.

  • Asset Applicability: An organization's selection of applicable assets, such as critical internet of things (IoT), terminals, operational technology (OT), and healthcare devices. The applicable assets inform which sections of NIST 800-53 are applicable and where NIST 800-53 does not provide coverage.

  • Threat Profile: An organization's selection of industry vertical could automatically inform a threat baseline for the organization. However, the organization may also incorporate specific objective knowledge to further inform their threat profile.

  • Business Impact Profile: An organization's link between their exposure profile and their applicable assets. This link informs the degree of confidentiality, integrity, and availability requirements per each of the organization's applicable assets.

The organization's inherent risk is based on the combination of exposure profile, asset applicability, threat profile, and business impact profile. Inherent risk tells the organization which risk scenarios are most risky and which loss categories are most concerning. This knowledge further informs the selection of NIST 800-53 controls that offer the most risk reducing benefit.

Example A: Top Risk Scenarios

In example A, we can see that crimeware (includes ransomware) intersecting with ICS/SCADA is the most risky scenario. This knowledge informs two choices:

  1. Pivoting: The organization should pivot from NIST 800-53 to NIST Special Publication 800-82, "Guide to Industrial Control Systems (ICS) Security" since it has been specifically tailored for ICS and OT environments.

  2. Control Selection: The organization should focus on NIST 800-53 controls that are effective countermeasure to crimeware. This would include (but not limited to) Awareness and Training, Program Management, and System and Information Integrity.

Example B: Top Control Domains

In example B, we can see that security awareness and skills training, service provider management (also known as supply chain management), and access control are the top 3 recommendations for improving cyber risk financial loss associated with the organization's exposure profile. The mapping of these control domains to NIST 800-53 prioritized NIST 800-53 controls as:

  1. Supply Chain Management

  2. Risk Assessment

  3. Personnel Security

  4. Identification and Authentication

  5. Awareness and Training

The selection of NIST 800-53 controls will be a unique exercise for each organization. As much as possible, organization's should try to avoid making decisions from hype and other concepts that suggest all controls are equal in reducing cyber risk.

In Summary

NIST 800-53 serves as a valuable resource for organizations seeking to establish a robust security and privacy framework for their information systems, and it provides a foundation for compliance with various security and privacy regulations and standards.

However, NIST 800-53 is not without its potential flaws or limitations. Every organization should be aware of these flaws and limitation and should have a plan overcome issues with complexity, lack of flexibility, lag in addressing emerging technologies, and other.

All organization's can use a cyber risk decision platform to tailor NIST 800-53 for their specific cyber risk needs.


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page